A bail hearing, sometimes called a show cause hearing, decides whether a person charged with a criminal offence can be released while their case goes through court and, if so, under what conditions. If police don’t release someone after an arrest, they must bring that person before a justice of the peace or judge without unreasonable delay. Where a justice is available, that must happen within 24 hours.
The law on bail changed significantly on 15 July 2026, when the Bail and Sentencing Reform Act (Bill C-14) took effect. This guide explains how bail works now, what happens at the hearing, and what to do if bail is denied.

Key Takeaways
- The Charter guarantees the right not to be denied reasonable bail without just cause.
- In most cases, the Crown must show why someone should stay in custody. In reverse onus cases, the accused must show why they should be released.
- Bail can be denied on three grounds: to make sure the accused attends court, to protect the public, or to maintain confidence in the justice system.
- Since 15 July 2026, more charges trigger a reverse onus, and some rules on sureties and release have become stricter.
- The Superior Court of Justice can review a detention order.
What Is Bail in Canada?
Bail, formally called judicial interim release, allows a person charged with an offence to remain in the community while their case moves toward trial. Section 11(e) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms protects the right “not to be denied reasonable bail without just cause”. That right reflects the presumption of innocence. Bail isn’t a punishment.
Release is the starting point. Section 493.1 of the Criminal Code tells police and courts to give primary consideration to releasing the accused at the earliest reasonable opportunity, on the least onerous conditions that fit the case. That’s why police release many people without a bail hearing.
In R v Antic, 2017 SCC 27, the Supreme Court of Canada explained the “ladder principle”. Courts should start with the least restrictive form of release and move up only if necessary. Since 15 July 2026, the ladder principle no longer applies where the accused faces a reverse onus. The law now also states that the principle of restraint doesn’t require release where detention is justified, including for public safety.
How Police Decide Whether to Release You
Not everyone who is arrested goes to a bail hearing. After an arrest, police can:
- release you with an appearance notice, which sets a court date
- release you on an undertaking, which sets a court date and can include conditions like no contact with the complainant
- hold you in custody for a bail hearing
Police hold people for bail in more serious cases, where there are safety concerns, or where the person is already on release for another charge. If you’re held, you have the right to speak to a lawyer before the hearing.
What Happens at a Bail Hearing?
Bail hearings take place in a bail court, where a justice of the peace hears most cases. The usual steps are:
- Preparing the release plan. Before court, defence counsel or duty counsel speaks with the accused and any proposed sureties. They gather details about where the accused will live, work, and spend their time, and build a release plan.
- The Crown’s position. The Crown decides whether to consent to release, consent with conditions, or seek detention.
- The allegations. In a contested hearing, the Crown reads a summary of the allegations and the accused’s criminal record, if any.
- Evidence from sureties. Proposed sureties testify about their relationship with the accused, their circumstances and how they’ll supervise. The Crown can cross-examine them to test the plan.
- Submissions. Each side argues whether release should be granted and on what terms.
- The decision. The justice either releases the accused on a release order, with any conditions, or orders detention.
- Release. Paperwork is completed, sureties acknowledge their obligations, and the accused is released from custody.
Consent Release vs a Contested Hearing
In many cases, the Crown and defence agree on release. The lawyers negotiate the conditions, with the defence aiming for the least restrictive terms that address the Crown’s concerns, and the judge approves the agreed release. Where the Crown opposes release, the hearing is contested and follows all the steps above.
How Long Does a Bail Hearing Take?
The court can deal with a consent release quickly once it reaches the courtroom. A contested hearing takes longer, especially when several sureties give evidence. A bail court with a full list may not reach every case on the scheduled day. The court can also adjourn a hearing for up to three days without the accused’s consent, and longer with it. Having sureties ready and reachable avoids unnecessary delay.
How Family and Friends Can Help
Family members and friends play a big part in most bail hearings. If someone close to you has been arrested, you can help by:
- contacting a lawyer as early as possible so that they can speak to the accused before court
- thinking about whether you could act as a surety, and how much you could pledge
- bringing ID and proof of your income, assets and address to court
- being ready to explain how you would supervise, including where the accused would live and your own work hours
Attending the hearing also shows the court the accused has community support. Some bail hearings take place by video, so check with the lawyer how and where to attend.

The Three Grounds for Denying Bail
Section 515(10) of the Criminal Code allows detention only on one or more of three grounds.
The primary ground: court attendance. Detention may be justified if it’s necessary to make sure the accused attends court. The court considers ties to the community, such as home, family, and work, as well as any history of missing court.
The secondary ground: public safety. Detention may be justified to protect the public, including the complainant and witnesses. That includes cases where there’s a substantial likelihood the accused would commit another offence or interfere with justice. The risk must be real, not just possible, and a strong supervision plan can address it.
The tertiary ground: confidence in the justice system. Detention may be justified to maintain public confidence in the administration of justice. The court weighs:
- the apparent strength of the Crown’s case
- the gravity of the offence
- the circumstances, including whether a firearm was used
- the potential for a lengthy prison sentence
- since July 2026, the number and seriousness of any outstanding charges
Our article on the tertiary ground explains it in more detail.
When making any bail decision, courts must also give particular attention to the circumstances of Indigenous accused and of accused from groups that are overrepresented in the criminal justice system. Since July 2026, they must also consider whether the alleged offence involved random or unprovoked violence. This applies to every bail decision, not just one of the three grounds.
What Is a Reverse Onus Bail Hearing?
In most cases, the Crown must show why detention is justified. In a reverse onus case, the accused must show why they should be released. Situations that trigger a reverse onus include:
- being charged with an indictable offence while already on release for another indictable offence
- certain firearm and weapons offences
- serious drug trafficking, importing or production charges
- failing to comply with a release order or failing to attend court
- intimate partner violence, where the accused has a prior conviction or discharge for violence against an intimate partner
- violent offences involving a weapon, where the accused has a similar conviction within 10 years of being charged and the maximum sentence for each offence is 10 years or more (the look-back period was 5 years before July 2026)
Since 15 July 2026, a reverse onus also applies to:
- violent or organised auto theft
- breaking into a home
- human trafficking and human smuggling
- assaults and sexual assaults involving choking, suffocation or strangulation
- extortion involving violence
- serious violent offences where the accused has two or more prior convictions for similar offences
In a reverse onus case, the ladder principle no longer applies, and the release plan carries more weight. The defence must show a credible plan, with suitable sureties and conditions, that addresses each ground of concern.

What Is a Surety and Who Can Be One?
A surety is a person, like a family member or close friend, who agrees to supervise the accused while they’re on bail. The surety promises the court an amount of money, called a pledge, that they may lose if they fail in their duties. In Ontario, most sureties pledge money rather than deposit it.
A surety’s role is to:
- make sure the accused follows every bail condition
- make sure the accused attends every court date
- report a breach of conditions to the police
Courts decide whether a proposed surety is suitable by considering their relationship with the accused, where they live, their ability to supervise, their financial means, and their own background. Since July 2026, a person convicted of an indictable offence in the past 10 years generally can’t act as a surety unless no other suitable surety is available and it’s in the interests of justice.
A surety who can no longer supervise can apply to the court to be relieved of their obligations. Read more in our articles on what a surety does and whether a person with a criminal record can be a surety.
Common Bail Conditions
Bail conditions should address the specific risks the court has identified. Section 515(4) of the Criminal Code allows conditions including:
- reporting to police or a bail programme
- living at a specified address and following a curfew or house arrest
- staying away from certain people or places, including no contact with the complainant or witnesses
- surrendering a passport and staying within a set area
- not drinking alcohol or using non-prescribed drugs, where linked to the allegations
- not possessing weapons
- electronic monitoring, in some cases
Since July 2026, courts must consider specific conditions for certain offences. Examples are no-contact and geographic conditions in extortion and organised crime cases, and curfews and device restrictions in auto theft and break-in cases.
What Happens If You Breach Your Bail Conditions?
Breaching a condition is serious. Depending on the circumstances, the consequences can include:
- A new charge. Failing to comply with a release order is an offence under section 145, with a maximum of two years’ imprisonment on indictment. For some minor breaches that cause no harm, police can instead refer the matter to a judicial referral hearing, where the court reviews the bail order without a new charge.
- Arrest and cancellation of bail. Police can arrest the accused, and the court can cancel the release order. At that hearing, the accused must justify being released again.
- Loss of the pledge. If the accused breaches bail, the Crown can apply to forfeit the surety’s pledge. At a hearing, the court decides whether, and how much, the surety must pay.
- Harder future release. A breach weighs heavily against release in any later bail hearing.
See our articles on failing to comply with bail conditions and our failure to comply defence page.
What If Bail Is Denied?
If the court orders detention, the accused stays in custody while the case continues. There are two main ways forward.
- Bail review. The accused can apply to the Superior Court of Justice to review the detention order. Under R v St-Cloud, 2015 SCC 27, the reviewing judge can intervene if the original decision contained an error of law, was clearly inappropriate, or if new, relevant evidence exists, such as a stronger surety or a treatment bed.
- A 90-day detention review. If the accused is still in custody 90 days after being detained and the trial hasn’t started, a judge must review whether continued detention is justified. The judge also looks at whether the case is moving forward without unreasonable delay.
- A new hearing if circumstances change. If something material changes, the accused may be able to bring a fresh bail application.
A bail review isn’t a fresh hearing. The reviewing judge works from the transcript and the original evidence, plus any new evidence. Coming back with a stronger plan than the first one is the most important part of the preparation.
While in custody, the defence can continue preparing the case. If release is still refused, the accused remains detained until a withdrawal, a plea or a trial resolves the charges.
Why Have a Lawyer at Your Bail Hearing?
Duty counsel, lawyers paid by Legal Aid Ontario, are available in bail court to help people without their own lawyer. A private lawyer can add time and preparation: speaking with sureties in advance, gathering documents like proof of residence or employment, building a detailed release plan, and negotiating conditions with the Crown.
The bail decision shapes everything that follows. Conditions can affect where you live, who you can see and whether you can work, sometimes for months. If you need help choosing a lawyer, our guide on finding a good criminal lawyer can help.
Speak to a Bail Hearing Lawyer
If you or someone close to you is being held for a bail hearing, early preparation matters. Pyzer Criminal Lawyers represents people at bail hearings and bail reviews across Toronto and the Greater Toronto Area. Consultations are free, confidential and carry no obligation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a Bail Hearing the Same as a Show Cause Hearing?
Yes. “Show cause hearing” is another name for a bail hearing. It comes from the rule that, in most cases, the Crown must show cause why it should detain the accused.
Can I Change My Bail Conditions?
Yes. If a condition becomes unworkable, for example because of a new job or a move, your lawyer can ask the Crown to agree to a variation. If the Crown doesn’t consent, you may need to apply to the court or seek a bail review. Read more about bail variations.
How Much Does It Cost to Bail Someone Out in Ontario?
In most Ontario cases, nobody pays money upfront. A surety pledges an amount, which they may have to pay only if the accused breaches the conditions and a court orders forfeiture. Cash deposits are ordered less frequently. Our article on how to bail someone out of jail explains the practical steps.
Do I Have to Answer Questions About the Charge at a Bail Hearing?
No. A bail hearing doesn’t decide guilt. Under section 518 of the Criminal Code, the justice can’t question the accused about the offence. If the accused testifies, the Crown can’t cross-examine them about the offence unless they’ve given evidence about it. Speak to a lawyer before saying anything about the allegations.
Can Someone Charged With Murder Get Bail?
Yes, but the process is different. For murder and the other most serious offences listed in section 469 of the Criminal Code, a justice of the peace can’t grant bail. The accused must apply to a judge of the Superior Court of Justice under section 522, and must show why detention isn’t justified. The same three grounds apply, and the tertiary ground carries particular weight in these cases.
Can a Surety Withdraw?
Yes. A surety who can no longer supervise the accused, or who has lost trust in them, can apply to the court to be relieved. The accused may then be taken back into custody unless the court approves a new surety or plan.
This article provides general legal information only and should not be construed as legal advice. Laws and their interpretation may change, and the application of law to specific circumstances requires professional legal assessment. If you have questions about a legal matter, please contact us for a free consultation.










